Have you ever felt the frustration of wanting to build strength at home but getting stopped by pricey equipment? I’ve been there—scanning endless options and wondering if quality and affordability can really go hand in hand. Finding the right weight bench doesn’t have to drain your wallet or clutter your space.

In this text, I’m diving into affordable weight benches that bring gym-level performance to your home without the hefty price tag. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned lifter, I’ll share insights that help you make smart choices and build a setup that works for you. Let’s cut through the noise and get you lifting with confidence.

Contents hide

Overview of Affordable Weight Benches for Home Gyms

Finding the right weight bench for a home gym can feel like a treasure hunt, especially when you want something budget-friendly without cutting corners on quality. Affordable weight benches these days offer a surprising blend of features that meet the needs of beginners and seasoned lifters alike (I speak from experience after testing several myself).

What really stands out with these benches is their smart balance of durability and compactness. Many models use sturdy steel frames and thick padding, so you get solid support during your workouts without the bench feeling like a bulky monster hogging half your room.

Adjustability is another big player here. You’ll find benches that shift from flat to incline and sometimes even decline positions making them versatile for exercises like bench presses, dumbbell rows, or crunches. This flexibility means you don’t have to buy multiple pieces of equipment, which keeps costs manageable.

Still, affordability doesn’t always mean everything in one package. Some benches might lack extras like wheels or storage racks, but honestly, if you’re short on space (aren’t we all), a lightweight, foldable bench can be a winner. It’s easy to move and tuck away after your session, which feels more like a bonus than a compromise.

A few stats I found helpful: a decent affordable bench can weigh between 20 and 40 pounds and handle between 300 to 600 pounds of user plus equipment weight. That’s often enough for most home gym warriors, unless you’re planning to bench press enough plates to require a forklift (if so hit me up with tips!).

Here are some tips from my bench-hunting journey to keep in mind:

  • Check max weight capacity but factor in your workout gear too, not just your body weight.
  • Padding thickness usually means comfort but look for high-density foam that doesn’t flatten after a few sessions.
  • Consider the bench’s footprint. Plenty of models fold flat to fit under a bed or behind a door.
  • Look for benches with multi-angle adjustments if you like switching up your routine.

Affordable weight benches are a practical investment that fits into everyday life—whether you squeeze in workouts before work or sneak a quick set while dinner cooks. They make lifting feel more inviting and doable, keeping you motivated without the intimidating vibe of a big commercial gym.

If you’re curious, I’ve seen users saying these benches keep them consistent with their fitness goals because using them is hassle-free and fits right into their usual schedule. Plus, they don’t expensive—making your home gym setup feel like a win from day one.

Key Features to Consider

Picking the right weight bench can feel like a big decision, especially when you want something affordable without giving up quality or flexibility. Here are the key features I’ve learned to watch for that make a bench fit perfectly into a home gym setup.

Weight Capacity

Your weight bench has to hold up to your body weight plus anything you’re lifting. I always check the weight limit before anything else. Most affordable benches support between 300 to 600 pounds, which usually covers casual lifters and even some intense sessions.

If you plan to add heavy dumbbells or barbells, lean toward benches with at least a 500-pound capacity. I once overlooked this and nearly bent my bench frame mid-squat—that’s a no-go in my book.

Quick Tip: Look for benches with steel frames — they tend to support more weight safely, even if they cost a bit more upfront.

Adjustability and Positions

This feature can turn a basic bench into your workout’s MVP. Adjustable benches let you switch between flat, incline, decline, and even upright positions. For me, this flexibility means I can hit more muscle groups without buying extra gear.

Some benches use simple knobs or pins to adjust angles, while others have more steps for fine-tuning. I prefer the latter since it feels sturdier and lets me find my perfect spot, especially when doing incline presses or seated curls.

Pro Tip: Even if you don’t think you’ll need all those positions now, having them can keep workouts fresh and help avoid plateaus.

Build Quality and Materials

The bench’s build is where you see if it’ll stick with you through sweat, spills, and a few accidental drops. A solid steel frame with a powder-coated finish feels like the sweet spot between durability and price here.

I always look at the seam and padding quality too. Thicker padding keeps things comfortable, but it shouldn’t be so soft that your back sinks in. And vinyl covers are great for wiping down after sweaty sessions.

Remember: A cheaper bench with flimsy materials often ends up costing more long-term when you factor in wear and needing replacements.

Size and Portability

Home gyms vary, so a bench that’s compact or folds up easily can be a real lifesaver. I’ve moved apartments with my bench (twice!), and the foldable design made it way less of a hassle.

If space is tight, look for benches that don’t dominate the room when folded or stored. Some models even have wheels to easily roll around.

Heads up: Don’t sacrifice sturdiness for size — a tiny, wobbly bench won’t motivate you back for day two.

Additional Attachments and Accessories

Some affordable benches come with extras like leg developers, preacher curl pads, or resistance band pegs. I’ve found these can add useful variety for a few extra bucks.

For example, leg developers help add hamstring and quad work right to your bench routine. And a preacher curl pad? Great for isolating those biceps without another machine.

That said, check if these extras are built well or just cheap add-ons. It’s better to get solid basics than a bench overloaded with wobbly attachments.


Quick Checklist for Your Next Weight Bench:

  • Weight capacity meets your lifting goals (body weight + weights).
  • Multiple adjustable positions for workout variety.
  • Strong steel frame with comfy, wipe-clean padding.
  • Size fits your space without compromise.
  • Useful attachments that feel sturdy and add workout value.

Getting the right weight bench is like picking your workout buddy — it should support you, challenge you, and stick around for the long haul. I’ve learned a lot through trial, error, and a few accidental dents (ouch!), so I hope these points help you find a bench you love.

Top Affordable Weight Benches for Home Gyms

Choosing the right weight bench can make your home workouts feel like a pro session without blowing the budget. I’ve tested several options that balance price, performance, and space-saving design so you can pick one that fits your routine and your room.

Fitness Reality 1000 Super Max Weight Bench Overview and Features

This bench stood out to me for its solid steel build and surprisingly high weight capacity of 800 pounds. That means whether you’re lifting solo or adding heavy dumbbells you won’t have to worry about stability. The backrest offers seven adjustable incline and decline positions. For flexibility enthusiasts like me who like to mix flat presses with seated shoulder work this was a real bonus.

Here’s a quick rundown:

  • Weight Capacity: 800 lbs (great for heavier lifting)
  • Adjustability: 7 backrest positions (flat, incline, decline)
  • Padding: Comfortable yet firm (avoids sinking during lifts)
  • Footprint: Compact enough for small spaces
  • Extras: Can attach leg developer for lower body exercises

I liked how setting it up was straightforward—no frustrating screws or leftover parts. It fits nicely in a corner but still feels sturdy under heavier lifts. Plus the price point was comfortably under $150 which makes it an easy pick for most budgets.

Marcy Adjustable Utility Bench Overview and Features

For a multipurpose bench with adjustable features but a budget-friendly tag this Marcy is a solid contender. The bench adjusts to incline, decline, and flat, giving me a full range of motion options. The cushion is thicker than I expected which really helps during longer sessions or when doing moves like dumbbell flyes that pressure your back.

Some features that caught my eye:

  • Weight Capacity: 600 lbs (enough for most users)
  • Adjustability: Incline, decline, and flat options
  • Padding: Plush cushioning for comfort
  • Portability: Lightweight and easy to move around
  • Build: Steel frame with anti-slip rubber feet to protect floors

If you have limited space or like to switch your home gym layout often this bench’s portability is a big plus. Just don’t expect it to handle extremely heavy loads like the Fitness Reality 1000. Still, for under $130, it’s fantastic for beginners or anyone wanting a reliable everyday bench.

Flybird Adjustable Bench Overview and Features

The Flybird bench is a favorite among home gym fans, and now I see why. It folds flat and even stands on its own for storage. This was perfect for my small apartment workout area where space is at a premium. The padded seat and backrest have thick, tear-resistant foam—comfort is never sacrificed.

Here’s why it worked for me:

  • Weight Capacity: 620 lbs (secure for medium-heavy use)
  • Adjustability: Multiple incline and flat positions
  • Space-saving: Foldable design with self-standing storage
  • Comfort: Thick, high-quality padding that’s easy to clean
  • Durability: Strong steel construction with powder-coated finish

One thing I appreciated was how the design helped steady my form during lifts. It felt sturdy enough for bench presses and seated exercises without wobbling. At about $140 it’s a great balance of comfort, strength, and convenience—perfect if you want to keep your workout gear tucked away when not in use.


Quick Tips To Choose Your Bench

  • Check Weight Capacity: Make sure it supports your body and the weight you intend to lift comfortably.
  • Look for Adjustability: Multiple incline positions unlock a wider range of exercises.
  • Consider Padding: Firm but comfortable cushions prevent slipping or discomfort.
  • Think About Space: Folding benches or compact designs can save your living area.
  • Extras Matter: Attachments like leg developers boost workout variety.

Finding an affordable weight bench that fits your style and space can feel like striking gold in your home workout journey. These three models offer quality, versatility, and friendly price tags—so you can confidently press, curl, and fly your way to stronger days ahead.

Performance and User Experience

Choosing an affordable weight bench for your home gym is about more than just price. How it performs during workouts and how comfortable and user-friendly it is can make all the difference. From my experience testing and using various benches, I’ve learned that aspects like stability, padding, and ease of setup really shape your workout quality. Here’s what I found most important for a seamless process.

Stability During Workouts

Nothing kills momentum faster than a bench that wobbles or shifts under pressure. Stability isn’t just about feeling safe; it also helps you lift better with confidence. While trying out benches like the Fitness Reality 1000 Super Max, I noticed its wide base and solid steel frame kept it rock steady—even during heavier lifts.

Some benches might look sturdy but end up rocking on uneven floors, which can be annoying at best and dangerous at worst. Here are a few tips to spot good stability:

  • Look for benches with rubber feet or non-slip padding to grip your floor.
  • Check for a wider stance—more surface area on the floor equals less wobble.
  • Pay attention to the material; thick steel tubing can withstand more weight and movement without bending.

If your workout space has hardwood or tiled floors, this matters even more since surfaces are slippery. A stable bench feels like a partner who’s got your back, helping you focus on your lifts rather than balancing acts.

Comfort and Padding

Comfort doesn’t get talked about enough in the budget bench scene but it can make or break longer sessions. A bench that’s too hard feels like sitting on a plank, while one with cheap foam can flatten out in weeks. When testing the Marcy Adjustable Utility Bench I found its medium-thick padding struck a nice balance—supportive enough for heavy reps and soft enough for comfort.

One thing I’ve learned is to look for benches with at least 2 inches of high-density foam. This kind of foam holds up over time and doesn’t squish down easily under your body weight. Plus, a quality vinyl cover can fend off sweat and clean up easily.

When shopping, rest on the bench for about 30 seconds—feels longer than it sounds! That little test helped me avoid benches that felt comfy at first but became painful when rested on more than a few reps.

Ease of Assembly

If you’re like me assembling furniture isn’t exactly a thrilling way to spend your day. So a bench that’s quick and simple to put together is worth its weight in gold. The Flybird Adjustable Bench was a pleasant surprise here—it took me under 20 minutes from box to workout ready with clear instructions and minimal tools.

Some benches come with confusing instructions and tiny bolts that make you want to call a professional help line (which, trust me, is easier than it sounds). Here’s how to keep assembly headaches at bay:

  • Pick benches that come mostly pre-assembled.
  • Look for user-friendly guides with pictures or videos.
  • Check if all required tools are included or if you’ll need extra screwdrivers or wrenches.

Quick setup means you start working out sooner and get straight to the good stuff instead of wrestling parts and piles of screws.


I’ve found that blending solid stability, comfortable padding, and easy assembly make a bench one you’ll actually use day after day. These features come together to create a supportive workout experience without burning a hole in your wallet. If you focus on a few key details like these, you can turn your everyday space into a fitness spot that feels welcoming and safe—no gym intimidation needed.

Pros of Affordable Weight Benches for Home Gyms

Affordable weight benches bring a lot to the table, especially when you’re setting up a home gym that won’t expensive or hog your space. I’ve spent a good chunk of time testing different benches, and here’s what I consistently see as the biggest advantages.

Wallet-Friendly Fitness

First off, the price tag. These benches don’t ask for a small fortune, so you can start building strength without feeling like you’re paying rent for fancy gear. For example, benches like the Marcy Adjustable Utility Bench often come in under $100, making them perfect for anyone watching their budget but still craving quality workouts.

Space-Saving Designs That Fit Your Home

Living in a small apartment or sharing space doesn’t mean you can’t have a solid workout setup. Many affordable benches are compact or foldable. The Flybird Adjustable Bench is a great example—it folds flat so it tucks away easily when you’re done. No need to sacrifice your living room’s floor space to get a good lift in.

Strong and Steady Support

You might think cheaper means flimsy, but plenty of these benches hold their ground surprisingly well. I’ve tested models that support up to 800 pounds—which covers most body weights plus heavy dumbbells or barbells. A sturdy steel frame and rubber feet usually help cut down wobble so you feel steady under load.

Adjustable Positions for More Exercise Variety

A bench that sits still is just a seat, right? The best affordable benches let you shift angles from flat to incline or decline. That means more exercises with the same equipment—bench press, shoulder raises, even some core workouts. Adjustability keeps your routine fresh and ensures every muscle group gets some attention.

Comfortable Enough to Keep You Coming Back

No one enjoys a bench that feels like a plank wrapped in sandpaper. Good padding in these affordable models usually means dense foam and a smooth vinyl cover. It’s enough cushion to keep your back comfy but doesn’t sacrifice stability. After a few sessions, I noticed my lower back thanking me for the support.

Quick Assembly Gets You Moving Faster

Some benches require a degree in engineering to set up. But, affordable options like the Flybird come with easy-to-follow instructions and clear labeling. I had mine ready for action in under 20 minutes (and that includes me fumbling the tools a bit). More time working out means less time wrestling with screws.

Helpful for All Levels: Beginners and Beyond

Affordable doesn’t mean basic—these benches work for newbies learning the ropes and seasoned lifters wanting to supplement gym days. I’ve seen people build consistent habits just by having a reliable bench at home (trust me, having easy access changes your motivation game).

Quick Tips to Choose Your Bench Wisely

  • Check weight capacity—aim for at least 500 pounds if you like heavier lifts.
  • Look for multiple adjustable settings to keep workouts varied.
  • Consider foldable models if space is tight.
  • Don’t skimp on padding for comfort over long sessions.

Still on the fence? Remember that investing in an affordable weight bench isn’t just about saving money—it’s about making strength training easy and accessible in your daily routine. Whether it’s a quick morning pump or an evening cooldown, these benches fit right in without asking for huge commitments.

Cons of Affordable Weight Benches for Home Gyms

Affordable weight benches bring a lot to the table for home workouts, but let’s get real—they aren’t without their quirks. From my experience and the times I’ve tested various models, here are some of the common downsides I’ve noticed that you might want to keep in mind.

Limited Weight Capacity Compared to Premium Benches

While many budget benches claim to hold impressive weights, they sometimes fall short when you start pushing heavy lifts. For serious lifters, this means you might run into limits sooner than with more expensive commercial-style benches. A bench that supports 300 to 500 pounds sounds decent, but if you’re adding heavy dumbbells or barbells on top, that weight stacks up quickly. I’ve seen some budget benches flex or wobble a bit at their limits, which can shake your confidence mid-set (literally).

Durability Over Time May Vary

Let’s face it—affordability usually means some trade-offs in materials. While many budget benches use steel frames, the gauge (thickness) of the metal or quality of welds might not match what you find in pricier models. This can lead to quicker wear or the need for repairs after constant use. I’ve had benches that started squeaking or showed rust spots after a year or two. That said, if you treat them well and avoid excessive moisture or overloading, many still hold up nicely for casual lifters.

Less Padding Comfort for Longer Sessions

Padding comfort is one area where you might notice a difference. The thicker high-density foam and premium vinyl covers found on higher-end benches often feel more supportive and last longer. Some affordable options use thinner padding or cheaper vinyl, which can get uncomfortable during longer workout sessions or certain poses like incline presses. If you plan to spend a lot of time on your bench, you might want to add a small cushioned cover or towel for extra comfort.

Adjustability Can Be Limited or Clunky

Many budget benches offer basic adjustability—think flat, incline, and decline positions. But the range or smoothness of these adjustments can feel limited or fiddly. Some benches require more effort and time to switch positions and might not lock as securely. I’ve found myself double-checking the locks during workouts just to be safe, which breaks the flow a bit. On the bright side, these benches usually cover the most popular angles well enough for standard workouts.

Bulkier Designs That Don’t Always Save Space

Affordable benches are often promoted as compact or foldable, but not all models actually make life easier when space is tight. Some benches fold but remain fairly large or awkward to store in small closets. Similarly, benches with wider bases for stability can eat up more floor space. I had one model that claimed to be foldable but required a nearly empty corner to fit. So, if space is premium, check dimensions carefully and maybe take a tape measure to your room before ordering.

Fewer Extras and Attachments

High-end benches sometimes come with handy attachments for leg curls, preacher curls, or black plate holders—features pretty much missing in the affordable range. That’s not a deal-breaker if you’re mainly focused on basic lifts, but worth noting if you enjoy more complex full-body routines. Most budget benches keep it simple: just a bench.

What I Take Away (Actionable Tips)

  • Keep your lifting goals in mind: If you expect to push heavy beyond 400 pounds regularly, look for benches with verified higher weight capacities.
  • Expect some compromise on comfort for the price; a small padded cover can help.
  • Test foldable or compact claims by measuring your actual space—dimensions can surprise you.
  • Double-check lock mechanisms for sturdiness to avoid mid-workout adjustments.
  • Think ahead about attachments—if you want extras later, you might need a different bench or add-ons.

Comparison with Premium Weight Benches

When I first started looking into weight benches for my home gym, I wondered how affordable models really stacked up against the premium ones you see in commercial gyms—or those with hefty price tags online. Spoiler alert: while premium benches offer some fancy perks, many affordable benches cover the essentials surprisingly well.

Build Quality and Materials

Premium benches typically use thicker steel frames and tougher welds, which means they often feel rock-solid and last longer under heavy use. You’ll notice less wobble when lifting big weights. Affordable benches usually have thinner frames and simpler construction, which can mean a bit more flex if you push them to extreme loads. For many home workouts this isn’t a deal breaker because most affordable benches still support between 500 to 800 pounds. (That’s enough for a solid arm day!)

Adjustability and Features

Premium benches often come with a flood of adjustable positions—from flat to incline, decline, and every angle in between. Plus, they may have extra gadgetry like leg developers, preacher curl pads, or storage racks. Affordable benches get this part right by focusing on the must-haves: flat, incline, and sometimes decline settings. I’ve found that limiting options isn’t a bad thing when you’re working out at home because it simplifies your routine and takes up less space.

Comfort and Padding

You probably won’t miss the luxury upholstery found on high-end benches when using an affordable model. Premium benches sometimes have thicker, softer padding that makes long sessions comfier. That said, many affordable benches feature high-density foam and decent vinyl covers that hold up well for normal workouts. For me comfort meant enough support to prevent pressure points without adding bulk.

Size and Portability

Here’s where affordable benches often shine. Premium models can be quite bulky and heavyweight, which poses a real headache if your home gym doubles as a guest room or office. I appreciated the foldable designs you find in budget-friendly options—they make it easy to tuck away your bench after a quick workout (which, trust me, is easier than it sounds). If you’re tight on space this portability feels like a game plan.

Price Versus Value

Premium benches can run upward of $500 to $1,000 or more, while affordable benches typically fall in the $100 to $300 range. That’s a big difference. For the serious lifter or commercial space, the extra cost may be worth it for the peace of mind and durability. But if you’re lifting at home a few times per week and don’t need those extra bells and whistles, affordable benches hit the sweet spot.

Here’s a quick breakdown comparing key points between the two:

Feature Affordable Weight Benches Premium Weight Benches
Weight Capacity 500–800 lbs 800+ lbs
Frame Thickness Moderate Thick, heavy-duty
Adjustability Flat, incline (sometimes decline) Multiple precise angles
Extra Features Minimal Leg developers, racks
Padding Quality Good foam, basic cover Thick foam, luxury materials
Size & Portability Compact, foldable options Mostly large and stationary
Price Range $100–$300 $500 and up

What I Keep in Mind

If you’re just setting up a home gym or easing into strength training you probably don’t need all the bells and whistles. I let ease of assembly, solid basic support, and compact storage guide me. But if weight is your obsession and you need a bench to last a lifetime without a second thought, then budgeting for a premium model can make sense.

Eventually it’s about matching the bench to your personal goals and lifestyle. I’ve had friends happily get their pump on with both types, which means there’s no one-size-fits-all answer—only the bench that fits your routine best.

Alternatives to Weight Benches for Home Workouts

Not everyone has the space or budget for a weight bench, and that’s perfectly okay. There are plenty of other solid options that can help you get a full-body strength workout right at home.

Stability Balls and Exercise Mats

Stability balls are fantastic for working your core, improving balance, and even doing presses or fly exercises you’d typically do on a bench. Use them on an exercise mat for extra comfort and grip. When I swapped a bench for a stability ball during a busy week, I was surprised at how much my core got involved—definitely a bonus!

Quick benefits:

  • Great for core activation and balance.
  • Portable and inexpensive.
  • Doubles as a stretching tool.

Foldable Step Platforms

Step platforms aren’t just for cardio. They can be a sturdy base for elevated push-ups, Bulgarian split squats, and seated dumbbell exercises. They store away nicely too—perfect if your space doubles as an office or living room.

Why I like them:

  • Lightweight and easy to move.
  • Versatile for strength and cardio.
  • Compact for small spaces.

Resistance Bands and Dumbbells

If lifting on a bench feels limiting, resistance bands and dumbbells add variety without bulky gear. Bands especially mimic the resistance you’d get on a machine, making your muscles work through the full range of motion.

Here’s a quick tip: Loop a resistance band around a sturdy chair or door frame to simulate bench press or rows. It’s a neat trick I use when traveling or when my bench is occupied.

Adjustable Floor Stations

Some adjustable floor stations are designed to provide incline/decline angles right on the floor for push-ups or sit-ups. They’re portable and lightweight, which means you can set up anywhere—even in your backyard. Plus, the angle adjustment adds variety to your routines without a full bench.

Why Consider Alternatives?

Switching things up makes workouts less boring and keeps your muscles guessing. And honestly, skipping a bulky bench can free up floor space, making your home gym feel less intimidating. Plus, alternatives often cost less and require less setup, so you can jump into your workout faster.

If you have tight space or just want something light to move around, these options might fit better than a traditional bench. They also make it easier to blend strength work with cardio and mobility on the same day.

Conclusion and Final Verdict

Choosing the right affordable weight bench for your home gym doesn’t have to be overwhelming. With careful consideration of features like weight capacity, adjustability, and build quality, you can find a bench that fits your space and training needs perfectly.

I’ve found that investing in a well-made, budget-friendly bench not only supports your fitness goals but also keeps your workouts consistent and enjoyable. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to upgrade, there’s an option that balances performance and value without very costly.

Eventually, the best bench is one that motivates you to keep lifting and growing stronger every day.

Frequently Asked Questions

What features should I look for in an affordable weight bench for home use?

Look for a sturdy steel frame, weight capacity of at least 500 pounds, adjustable positions, comfortable padding, and a compact or foldable design for easy storage.

Can affordable weight benches support heavy lifting?

Yes, many affordable benches support between 500 to 800 pounds, sufficient for most home workouts, but check the specific model’s weight limit before purchasing.

Are foldable weight benches better for small spaces?

Foldable benches are ideal for saving space, but make sure to test their dimensions and locking mechanisms to ensure they are both compact and stable.

How important is adjustability in a weight bench?

Adjustability is key for variety. Multiple positions (flat, incline, decline) allow you to perform varied exercises without needing multiple benches.

What are the common drawbacks of affordable weight benches?

They may have limited durability, less comfortable padding, fewer adjustment options, and sometimes less effective space-saving designs compared to premium models.

How do affordable benches compare to premium models?

Premium benches typically have better build quality, thicker frames, enhanced comfort, and more features, but affordable options still deliver essential performance for home use.

Can beginners use affordable weight benches effectively?

Yes, affordable benches are great for all fitness levels, offering stability and adjustable options that help beginners learn proper form and progress gradually.

Are there alternatives to weight benches for home workouts?

Yes, alternatives include stability balls, foldable step platforms, resistance bands, adjustable floor stations, and dumbbells, which save space and increase exercise variety.

How do I ensure a weight bench will be comfortable?

Check for thick high-density foam padding and durable vinyl covers that offer both support and comfort during longer workout sessions.

Is assembly difficult for affordable weight benches?

Most affordable benches are designed for quick and easy assembly, with some models like the Flybird Adjustable Bench requiring only a few minutes to set up.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published